Yeast #10: Gooey Butter Cake

116When I started this yeast resolution almost a year ago, I have to admit I had a lot of trepidation.  I knew I could try it — fear of cooking is not my issue.  I just didn’t expect things to go so well.  There have been some mishaps along the way — all caused by me — but when they happened, I knew enough either about yeast by then or cooking in general to keep moving.  When the worst test came up and everything went wrong and it still turned out ok, I knew I was going to be fine.  At that point, I should have decided “I win” and just stopped.  That was July.

I didn’t stop.  I kept going and things have still been turning out well.  I have learned enough to know when to push things and when to hold back.  And I have to say I feel really no fear when it comes to working with yeast.  So in that respect, it’s been an unmitigated success.

Now, though, in the final stretch for the year, it’s feeling a bit like a burden.  I still like doing the projects, but sometimes trying to hit the task before the month ends can be a bit tricky.  I’ve been trying for a couple of weekends to do the yeast project for October but it kept getting shifted.  Finally this weekend it was do it or miss the goal, so I got into the kitchen.  I won’t miss the influence of the calendar once the year ends.  I look forward to doing these projects when I want to and not feeling like I have to do them.  Of course I know the only rule maker is me so I could stop, but I’m so close now.  Why stop now?

One of my friends and I were talking and she assumed I had mapped out the full year.  I hadn’t and still haven’t.  I knew that at least one month would be the cinnamon rolls I tried to make years ago that failed horribly, but I had no idea what month they would appear.  I had decided to make them this month until something else caught my eye.  For every month, I gathered some of the recipes I had saved from over the years and looked to see what might be good.  Initially I was looking for no-fail recipes to give myself a boost.  Then I was looking for things where yeast — and not killing it — would be a bit more challenging.  Once I could make bread, I wanted to try making things with ingredients I like like olives, buttermilk, corn meal and cheese.  All along I’ve been following whims or taking suggestions from friends.  I only repeated a recipe once so far, but that was mostly so my parents to could taste a loaf I thought was especially good.

This month I was looking at the cinnamon roll recipe I thought I’d be making — the one with which I had previously failed.  I was also watching an episode of Martha Bakes at the same time and she made a recipe for a St. Louise butter cake.  I was intrigued by the look of it.  On the bottom was a slightly sweet yeast dough and it was covered on top by some butter-filled concoction.  As the two layers baked together, some kind of alchemy occurred to create the final product.


My mom’s kuga based off of the kuga her mom used to make. This is what I thought this cake might be similar to, but I was wrong…

I was intrigued.  I was thinking it might be similar to the kuga (coffee cake) my grandmother made and my mom now makes.  I was not exactly correct in that assumption.

It looked to be a much easier recipe than the cinnamon rolls since no rolling or slicing was involved and the rise time was just one hour and the back time was 20 minutes.  Since I wanted to make it on a Sunday I also hoped to make lasagna, it had the ‘quick’ finish time I was looking for so I set out to make it.

This recipe calls for 3 sticks of room temperature butter.  I always have butter in my house, but usually it’s in the freezer.  By the time I knew this was my recipe, it was still in the freezer, so it was just easier to run out and buy a new pound of butter so at least it would be refrigerator temperature.

094 095

For the dough, I pushed it by warming the first stick of butter slightly in the microwave.   I probably took it a little too far because I wanted soft but what I had was partially melted.  I then overheated my milk by a smidge as well.  I put the milk in the freezer to cool it down and mixed into my melty/soft butter most of the other ingredients:

  • 1/2 cup (1 stick) unsalted butter, room temperature
  • 1/4 cup granulated sugar
  • 1 teaspoon coarse salt
  • 2 large eggs
  • 1 cup all-purpose flour – recipe calls for 2, but this is where I started

Because the butter was really soft, it was a breeze to mix in the sugar, salt, eggs, and 1 cup of flour.  Because Martha had made a point of mixing the yeast/milk mixture in with the flour, I didn’t want to completely move away from her instructions in case they might be meaningful.

096 098

Once my milk had cooled to about 100 degrees, I mixed in the one packet of yeast.

  • 1/4 cup warm whole milk
  • 1 envelope active dry yeast

After letting is sit for a few minutes to begin to develop, I mixed it in with the last of the flour.

  • 1 cups all-purpose flour

100It came together as a very soft dough ball that was very easy to spread into a greased 9×11 inch pan.  All that was left at that point was to cover it with wrap and put it in a warm location for an hour.  I had briefly (minutes!) heated my oven to make it a bit warm.  I put the pan of dough and a bowl with my other two sticks of butter into the oven to rise and to bring the butter to room temperature.

105 107

When the dough had been rising for nearly an hour — it gets very yeasty smelling and a nice lumpy top appears — I got to making the topping.  The topping is like a combination of buttercream frosting and sugar cookie dough.  It didn’t exactly turn out the way I expected.  I thought it would be more liquid and similar to what tops my grandmother’s kuga.  Instead, it’s a butter/sugar bonanza that you “frost” on to the yeast dough base.

Using my hand mixture (easier than digging out my stand mixer), I blended the topping ingredients:

  • 1 cup (2 sticks) unsalted butter, room temperature
  • 1 1/3 cups granulated sugar
  • 3/4 teaspoon coarse salt
  • 1 large egg, plus 1 large yolk
  • 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
  • 1 1/3 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1/4 cup light corn syrup

108 111

I started with the sugar and butter and salt and creamed like making cookies.  I then added in the egg and extra yolk, the vanilla extract, and the corn syrup.  Finally I mixed in the flour.  It was very much like frosting/cookie dough at this stage.

The key is getting it spread on the dough without deflating the dough.  It helps to make some strategic “blobs” of the topping all over the surface of the dough.  Once mostly spread around, you then gently spread the topping evenly over the top.  If you have an offset spatula, I’m sure that works best.  I just used a kitchen knife and took my time not to push down too hard.  The one mistake I might have made was pushing the topping all the way to the edges.  If I made it again, I’d leave a small border around the edge to allow the bottom layer to puff up more on the edges.

113 114

The amazing thing is that the recipe then just takes a quick 20 minutes or so in the oven at 350 degrees.  I cooked mine a few minutes more but I think that’s because I couldn’t gauge the browning since my edges were under the topping.  I probably could have stopped at 20 minutes.119

Here’s the key:  let it cool completely to room temperature.  I didn’t, and it was an oozing mess.  A couple of the pieces I couldn’t have served to anybody but myself from the looks of them and I scooped them into a bowl to try to help them from oozing any more than they already had.  Once cooled, the gooey stop still stays gooey but it doesn’t run off of the base.

128That mistake aside, it is delicious but it’s super, super, SUPER rich.  For me, one piece was about as much of it as I wanted to eat.  Best to make it when you have friends who can help you finish it.  I did give some away and I’ve made myself work through another piece of it, but it’s so sweet.  Even with a cup of dark, black coffee, it’s pretty intense.

If I were to make it again, I’d probably reduce the topping by half.  I really liked the flavors of the yeast dough base and the topping is good, but it’s just too much of a good thing for me.

Still, the yeast developed without a hitch, so that’s a win for me!  Yeast attempt #10 is a success.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s